Painting-on-Sea (1) notes (ii)

To Newlyn!

In the introductory notes, I suggested a few ideas that might guide the way we think about artists on the coasts in the late 19th century: from the naval story of Britain through to geological sciences the fashions for tourism. Alongside French art and artists influenced their British counterparts: from Millet and the Barbizon School’s investigation of ‘rural realism’ to Jules Bastien-Lepage’s painting techniques.

Back in Britain, we might note the artist James Clarke Hook (1819-1907) who, from the mid-1850s began working in Clovelly on the north Devon coast and introduced a generation of artists and viewers to “coastal topography and atmospherics” –

“Fishing, unloading catches, mending boats, nets and lobster cages became rich sources of subject matter, upon which grander themes, to do with the family, social cohesion in coastal communities, primitive religion and superstition… could be written” (Kenneth McConkey in “Painting at the Edge” pp.11).

(picture c/o Bridgeman Art Images)

James Clarke Hooke’s “Welcome, Bonny Boat!” – the Fisherman’s Return, Clovelly, North Devon (1856; Harris Museum, Preston) shows, in these earlier works, how indebted he remained to the Pre-Raphaelite style and palette – those high colours and the woman on the steps looking positively Arthurian. It also taps into the Victorian love of narrative and sentimentality – the hint of tragedy that the fisherman may not have returned from his fishing-trip, the relief of his homecoming and the cute joy of the welcoming child.

Crabbers (1876, Manchester Art Galleries) is somewhat different with its rather more invigorating realism: the swell of the sea and the force of the spray are palpable; we are ‘in’ the boat with the working-men up close and personal; and although ‘posed’ these are portraits of real men.

As Kenneth McConkey points out, Clovely became a sort-of artists colony as a number of artists did follow him. But it is Newlyn that becomes the first ‘real’ artists colony.

One of the earliest arrivals was Walter Langley (1852-1922) – a watercolour (primarily) artist from Birmingham who took to the subjects of the fishing village and its often precarious life. Langley’s most famous work is:

Among the Missing (1884, Penlee House Gallery). Again, this taps into the Victorian desire for drama and a certain fatalistic melancholy, yet the scene also conveys the very real horrors of the fishing community. The men would go out many miles to sea for days at a time. Here, Langley shows the village Post Office – a telegram has been pasted onto the noticeboard to inform the villagers that one of the fishing fleet has been lost, naming the boat and the men.

Along similar narrative vein is Frank Bramley (1857-1915)’s

A Hopeless Dawn (1888, Tate)

The title of this painting comes from a passage by John Ruskin, which affirms that Christ is at the helm of every boat. The kneeling woman, comforted by her mother-in-law, realises that her husband is lost at sea, but the open Bible, altar-like table and print on the wall hint at the consolations of religion –

It is perhaps the work of Stanhope Forbes (1857-1947) that really brought Newlyn to the attention of the viewing public with Fish Sale on a Cornish Beach (1885; Plymouth Museums):

This extraordinary painting combines the realism of James Clarke Hook with the open-air vitality of Jules Bastien Lepage. It took about 6 months to paint, the artist out in all weathers to achieve his effect. The group at the foreground are apparently discussing the catch and prices, focused and intense, with the fish displayed around their feet. In the middle ground we see the rest of the community to the right and a brilliantly sky-mirroring area of lying seawater – the line of people and reflective water demarcating the margin of beach and sea. Then the eye is led – via the figures and rowing boat – to the cluster of fishing boats on the horizon. The painting is powerfully designed for the viewer’s eye to cross the horizontals and enter the distances and depths of the scene.

And whilst Stanhope Forbes was apparently none-too-enamoured about the work of James Whistler, there are echoes – from the bands of colour, light and subject that stabilise the design to the perfect tones of greys, blues and browns that give the painting wholeness. Whilst Whistler aimed for a decorative beauty however, Forbes is keen to capture the realism of the event and indeed the naturalism of the slowly lightening day, the still-grey sands and the cool blue-grey sea.

Often forgotten is Elizabeth Forbes (1859-1912; nee Armstrong), a Canadian-born artist who became Stanhope’s wife – together they would open the Newlyn Art School in 1899. Her paintings also bring this sense of open-air realism, drawing on the style of Bastien Lepage whilst portraying scenes from the local everyday community:

April (no date; Wikipedia Commons). Again, notice the forefronted portrait against a looser ‘square-brush’ background which gives that sense of open air, freshness and movement.

Such a realist approach to painting became the hallmark of the Newlyn Colony through the 1880 and 1890s, and similar influences were developing in artist communities around the coasts of Britain.

Our next meeting is

Saturday 25th February, 10.30-12.30 at The Beecroft Gallery, Southend-on-Sea

Heavy Weather in Staithes (1890s)

With the developing focus on realist portrayals of working life and an increasing interest in the representation of light, we move this month up the coast to colonies including Walberswick and Staithes, where life in the 1890s is one of harsh beauty. Here we meet Laura Knight at the start of her artistic journey from dark Dutch interiors to the seaside and sunlight.

Tickets for each session cost £10 and include tea/coffee (biscuits!) and resource materials for independent research.

For further information and to enrol, please contact Mark Banting:









About TheCommonViewer

Independent Researcher: gently exploring "The Art & Artists of Russia (1850s-present) currently, and please see the A History of Art in England series; looking forward to discussing "British Art Groups (1930s)" when we can have live group meetings again! Twitter: @TheCommonViewer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: